top of page

Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ): Turning Data into Dollars

Oct 6

3 min read

0

3

Every organization carries a silent drain on its profits—errors, rework, warranty claims, and customer dissatisfaction. In Lean Six Sigma, the Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) is the metric that brings these hidden costs into the light. By expressing inefficiency in dollars and cents, COPQ gives leaders a compelling reason to act.


What Is COPQ?

According to the American Society for Quality (ASQ), COPQ refers to “the costs associated with providing poor-quality products or services.” These are costs that would disappear if processes were perfect. In other words, COPQ is the financial impact of defects and inefficiencies—not just on the production floor, but across the entire value chain.

Another way to view it is as a subset of the Cost of Quality (COQ). Some quality costs are investments in prevention and appraisal, while COPQ specifically covers costs due to nonconformance.


Components of COPQ

COPQ is typically broken into four major categories:

  1. Prevention Costs – Investments made to prevent defects such as training, process redesign, and supplier audits.

  2. Appraisal Costs – Costs of inspection, testing, audits, and quality checks.

  3. Internal Failure Costs – Costs arising from defects found before delivery, such as scrap, rework, and machine downtime.

  4. External Failure Costs – Costs imposed after delivery—warranty claims, returns, and reputation damage.

ASQ emphasizes that quality improvement should aim to reduce internal and external failure costs by investing more in prevention and appraisal.

For example, suppose a software services company receives numerous bug complaints from clients after a release. Fixing those post-release bugs, responding to customer dissatisfaction, and offering patch support all count as external failure costs.


Why COPQ Matters

  1. Creates Urgency – Leaders often respond faster when inefficiency is expressed in dollars. COPQ speaks management’s language.

  2. Prioritizes Projects – You can compare COPQ by process or department and choose improvement projects with the highest financial return.

  3. Drives Investment in Quality – It justifies spending on prevention and process improvements because you can show ROI.

  4. Reveals Hidden Costs – Much of COPQ is “below the waterline”—loss of customer goodwill, lost sales, and risk exposure.

In fact, ASQ notes that for many organizations, COPQ may represent a significant percentage of operating costs or sales.


Turning Data into Dollars: How to Compute COPQ

  1. Define the scope – Identify which processes or departments to analyze.

  2. Collect data – Capture prevention, appraisal, internal failure, and external failure costs.

  3. Validate with finance – Ensure cost allocations are acceptable to accounting.

  4. Use Pareto analysis – Focus on the biggest contributors to COPQ.

  5. Implement improvements – Apply Lean Six Sigma tools such as mistake proofing or control charts.

  6. Track results over time – Compare COPQ before and after to validate impact.

Let’s say a manufacturer finds that internal rework costs for a particular machine line are $200,000 a year. By investing $50,000 in improved standard work and maintenance, the rework drops to $50,000. The net COPQ reduction is $150,000—a clear financial gain.


Challenges & Best Practices

  • Hidden costs are difficult to quantify—lost customers, brand damage, morale losses.

  • Over-attribution – Don’t blame all defects on operator error; consider systemic causes.

  • Cross-functional input – Involve quality, production, finance, and customer service teams.

  • Continuous updating – As improvements are made, the baseline COPQ changes; recalculate periodically.


Final Thoughts

COPQ is more than a metric—it’s a strategic lens. It helps organizations see where inefficiencies bleed profit and guides teams toward high-impact improvements. When data becomes dollars, quality stops being an abstract concept and becomes a boardroom priority.

By calculating and acting on COPQ, you make a convincing case: better quality doesn’t cost more—it saves money.


References

Related Posts

bottom of page